Skip to main content

The Vanuccis of Carmignano


“Not a Carmignano”,  I recalled telling Steve, my importer, when he mentioned the initial contact he had with Silvia Vanucci of Piaggia.  “ Number one-they’re never ripe, number two-Cabernet has no business being planted in Tuscany, and number three-they simply don’t sell” I protested not too delicately.  This occurred just about a year ago, right around the time I had the chance to attend the Gambero Rosso Tre Bicchiere tasting in New York.  It was here by coincidence that I met Silvia Vanucci, who was pleasantly standing behind her table pouring tastes of her ’08 Carmignano Riserva.  Wow, was I about to be schooled!  The wine was nothing like any other Carmignano I had ever tasted...ripe, seductive and richly textured.  It was nothing short of magnificent and far better integrated than many of the renowned Super-Tuscans I had the opportunity to try at the event.  I reached for my phone and called Steve...

Perhaps the reason that a well-made Carmignano should be better than most modern Super-Tuscans lies in the history of the appellation.  It was in the 18th century that producers in Carmignano began the tradition of blending Sangiovese and Cabernet together.  They had roughly a 200 year advantage on their peers who only recently have jumped on the Super-Tuscan bandwagon.  So while it was always in the region’s DNA, it is the exception rather than the rule that the wine reaches the heights that it does at Piaggia.  As Silvia explained, there remains a culture in the appellation to harvest more according to tradition than to taste and complete ripeness.  And this is what makes the wines of Piaggia so very special.  

A little background.  The region was given DOC status in 1975 and DOCG status in 1990.  The laws on blending are as follows.  Sangiovese can be a minimum of 50% to a maximum of 90%.  Cabernet (Sauvignon or Franc) can be a minimum of 10% to a maximum of 20%.  Canaiolo can be blended up to 20%.   Merlot, Mammolo, Colorino and white grapes can also be used.

After our tour of Piedmont, we headed to Tuscany to visit some of our producers there, Piaggia was the first stop.  Located just outside and to the Northwest of Florence, one can feel the proximity to the city in this pretty suburban appellation.  With gently rolling hills and lovely vistas, Carmignano retains much of it’s rural nature, nestled quietly just beyond the din of the city.  Piaggia is a very small father-daughter operation founded in the mid ’70’s by Mauro Vanucci. Mauro was quietly tending an impressive grill fire as we arrived.   It is now run by his daughter Silvia.  Silvia took us through the vineyards and it was evident that, over the years, her father had acquired some of the finest parcels in the appellation including a 15 ha parcel around a natural basin just a few hundred yards from the center of Carmignano.

During our tasting we were treated to the fruits of Mauro’s labors with the fire he was tending upon our arrival.  He arrived with a huge doublecut “porterhouse” bistecca Fiorentina, which I presumed we all would share...then he produce three more, one for each of us.  Needless to say, a terrific visit with Piaggia, but one that required a serious nap afterward.  


Tasting Notes:

’10 Pietranera (100% Sangiovese IGT)  Brilliant redfruits on nose with lively cedar and leather tones.  Fresh, and vibrant on palate with deep well-integrated flavors.

’10 Il Sasso, single vineyard Carmignano (70% Sangiovese, 15% Cab. Sauv and Cab. Franc, 10% Merlot)  Rich, velveteen nose with dark cedar fruits and spice.  Tight, now but well structured.

’09 Il Sasso  Ripe forward and lush nose.  Supple, and silken on palate with broad dark fruit flavors and seductive textures.  These are incredible values in Carmignano.

’08 Piaggia Carmignano Riserva VV (3 years aging prior to release= riserva)  2 years in oak.  Rich, seductive nose with pepper and spice.  Sweet flavors of rich fruit and camphor on palate.

’08 Poggio di Colli  (Cabernet Franc)- Earthy, cedary sandalwood tones on nose.  Lively, lush and racy on palate.  This is impeccable wine and among the great Cab. Francs of Italy.  

’09 Poggio di Colli  Deep, dark rich complex blackfruits and spice on nose.  Serious flavors on palate with firm, diciplined structure.  Incredible wine.

’10 Poggio di Colli  Savory basil tones on nose.  Quite young now, but showing a meatiness now which should make this a long-lived profound wine.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Soils of St. Nicolas de Bourgueil

Whether they come from Chinon, Samur or Bourgueil, Cabernet Franc based reds from the Loire conjure Laphroaig-esque impressions to knowing wine drinkers.  They are often pungent, herbaceous, wildly complex wines with a small cult-like well-read fan-base.    Not in the mainstream for sure.    Just as Laphroaig is not indicative of all single malts, reds from the Loire region don't all share these same outsized traits. The wines from Xavier Amirault are just such an exception and it's not by accident that Vineyard Brands, an importer with deep roots in burgundy would be the kind of company to bring these wines into the United States. Land close to the banks of the Loire river is quite fertile and is reserved for cereals and pasture. Things begin to get interesting as one moves upwards from lower valley.    Lower parcels in the Clos de Quarterons, the Amirault family's estate, have deep (up to 25 feet) gravelly soils which drain well and where generous ra...
Post a Comment
Read more

Bourgogno Barbera, Just Right

2009 Borgogno Barbera  OK, I'll be honest, this producer is nostalgic for me. When I was a kid growing up in New Jersey, one of my idols was my Sicilian grandfather... Grandpa Lanza. Grandpa Lanza loved to cook, grow things and make wine. He lived in Staten Island and would host most of the important family gatherings. My love affair with food all started under his gentle guidance. While he drank simple wines most of the time, he would occasionally buy something special for the holidays. I distinctly recall one Thanksgiving Dinner where the turkey sat like a figurehead amongst caponata, sausage, baked pasta and other Italian delights. On the table that day was a bottle of Borgogne Barolo. The label today is unchanged from what it was in the early '70's. Back then it was among precious few serious Italian wines imported into the US. Borgogno is now with Domaine Select and representing them is somewhat of a coming full-circle for me. There is a little of the '09 Barbera t...
Post a Comment
Read more

Thomas Jefferson in Chianti

Not too long ago I had the chance to visit Monticello, the home of Thomas Jefferson in Charlottesville, VA.   I was surprised to learn there that despite all of his worldly achievements what Mr. Jefferson desired most was a domestic existence at Monticello where he could pursue his studies of science, engineering and agriculture.  As amazing as the house and buildings are at Monticello, the gardens there are no less so. The gardens have been restored to show Jefferson's experiments in domestic crops of vegetables, cereals, orchards and vineyards.  It was clear that he was keenly focused on how best to utilize each acre of his land. Shortly after my visit to Monticello, I was in Italy visiting producers in Tuscany and upon arriving at Bibbiano in Castellina in Chianti I began to have flashbacks of Jefferson's Monticello.  You see Bibbiano is more than just another Chianti producer.  It is a rather large estate, a distinct "place" in the Chianti Classico with a lo...
Post a Comment
Read more